Fantasy Bay

★★★★★

“I've been going to Fantasy Bay on/off for years. Whenever I'm in Bayonne it's a must on my many stops. The owner is super nice and welcoming. I look forward to seeing all the new things she has, and her events are always fun. Recently it looks like they've managed to get some help online with their discord. It looks cleaner, more organized, and professional, and I like that I can see all the events coming up so I can better plan my trips. Looking forward to stopping by again when I'm in the area..”

★★★★★

“Great anime tcg hobby store, events are fun and enjoyable. Today was different bringing some anime culture into Bayonne with the maid cafe, was definitely and interesting experience wish I could of stayed longer, might frequent a bit more lol”

★★★★★

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Absolutely love Fantasy Bay! This is hands-down one of my favorite local spots in Bayonne. Whether you're into trading card games, board games, or collectibles, Fantasy Bay has it all. The store is super organized, clean, and welcoming—and the staff is incredibly friendly and knowledgeable. They’re always happy to help whether you’re a beginner or a longtime collector. I’ve picked up some great finds here, and I love how they support the community with events and tournaments. It’s a perfect place to shop, hang out, or just browse if you're into anything fantasy, anime, or gaming related. Highly recommend stopping by if you're in the area!”

★

“Came here for my first visit , so excited to check out the pokemon collection. As I entered i felt judged right away. I was looking at everything on the counter and felt the person just giving me the most negative energy. I proceed to say hello and ask if they have any pokemon cards , the person behind the counter gave me little to no information, was extremely unfriendly. The look of judgement she gave me was insane.The shop was completely dead by the way , as soon as I felt that negativity I turned around and left. Walked right down the block to Manifest Comics was was treated with respect .”