Not A Lucky Mimic
2337 Dayton Germantown Pike · Dayton, OH 45327
Not A Lucky Mimic is a trading card shop at 2337 Dayton Germantown Pike in Dayton, Ohio. The shop carries Magic: The Gathering. Store details last verified Sunday, November 8, 2026.
Not A Lucky Mimic is a card shop in Dayton, OH carrying Magic: The Gathering. Google reviewers mention sealed product and events and play space. Open seven days a week. Located at 2337 Dayton Germantown Pike.
- Address
- 2337 Dayton Germantown Pike, Dayton, OH, 45327
- Phone
- (937) 895-0260
- Games
- Magic: The Gathering
- Services
- Call to confirm
- Rating
- ★ 4.8 (16)
- Verified
- Sunday, November 8, 2026
Community rating
4.8★
Based on 16 ratings
Be the first local to vote · 4.8 on Google
Beloved
Rate it
Hours of operation
- Mon
- 6pm – 10pm
- Tue
- 6pm – 10pm
- Wed
- 6pm – 12am
- Thu
- 6pm – 12am
- Fri
- 6pm – 12am
- Sat
- 6pm – 12am
- Sun
- 6pm – 12am
Games carried
- Magic: The Gathering
Services
Not verified yet — buylist, grading drop-off, and event details vary by shop.
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap
Own Not A Lucky Mimic?
Claim this listing to update hours, photos, games, and events — and put the “Find us on CardsNearby” badge on your site. Free.
From Google reviews
What collectors say
★★★★★
“The store has excellent prices, comfortable atmosphere, plenty of play spaces for MTG, Warhammer, Necromunda, and tabletop RPG such as DnD, offers the most competitive prize support available to them as a newer and smaller store. They also have some of the best deals, such as buying an MTG precon deck you get a great discount on sleeves and deck boxes for each precon purchased. They also have binders of cards for you to go through, display cases full of sought after rares, booster packs to purchase, and their entire inventory is catalogued and itemized and can quickly tell if they have a particular single you're looking for.”
★★★★★
“I had an excellent time here on opening day. There are a ton of tables to play magic the gathering as well as other games so you can bring an event here to get some games going. they have 3 war game tables and a collection of terrain and scenery to get you immersed while playing. Also they have board games for open play so you can always learn something new. The store is mainly focused on magic, they have many different products that are hard to come by for commander. the organization of all the cards they have is well managed making it super easy to ask for any card that you need, they always get back to you with little to no delay. I am looking forward to coming to this card shop for years to come, seeing the community along the way.”
★★★★★
“Definitely a gaming store in the area that deserves more attention. Friendly staff. Competitive pricing. Wide array of gaming options and events. The owner is very personable and will sit down and game with you if time allows. I really like Mimic.”
★★★★★
“Been here a few times now. the staff is amazing. I'm newer to mtg they've been very helpful with any questions. I've had they also have a great atmosphere around the shop everyone is nice and you can tell they really care about the community as well.”
Good to know
Common questions
What does Not A Lucky Mimic carry?
Not A Lucky Mimic carries Magic: The Gathering. Call (937) 895-0260 to check current inventory.
Where is Not A Lucky Mimic located?
Not A Lucky Mimic is at 2337 Dayton Germantown Pike in Dayton, Ohio 45327.
Within 50 miles
Card shows nearby
Keep browsing