Sammis Heartfelt Treasures
25 W 9th St · Erie, PA 16501

Sammis Heartfelt Treasures is a Erie destination for collectibles and trading cards, rated 4.5 stars across 18 Google reviews. Open 6 days a week. Located at 25 W 9th St.
Hours
- Mon
- 10am – 6pm
- Tue
- 10am – 6pm
- Wed
- 10am – 6pm
- Thu
- 10am – 6pm
- Fri
- 10am – 6pm
- Sat
- 11am – 5pm
- Sun
- Closed
Games
- Other TCG
Services
Not verified yet — buylist, grading drop-off, and event details vary by shop.
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap
Own Sammis Heartfelt Treasures?
Claim this listing to update hours, photos, games, and events. Free.
From Google reviews
What collectors say
★★★★★
“If you’re the kind of person who also gets warm and fuzzy community feelings from an inspirational small business, you will appreciate Sammi’s Heartfelt Treasures. This is a store with an inspirational owner, a BUNNY who LIVES there, and an amazing inventory that kept me there for hours. It’s a craft store but it does not limit itself. Michele, store owner and master crafter, told my grandma and I that if we couldn’t find something we wanted there, she’d find a way to get it made!!! I never even planned on walking in to this charming vendor consignment store and I definitely did not expect to make an emotional human connection with the owner that really lifted me up. This place has good stuff and great people. It reminded me of how beautiful it actually is for resilient community builders to not only take the first leap, but show up each day to make their vision a reality. Right near State Street in Erie, just a block away from some other classics like the Purrista Cat Cafe, I recommend taking a look inside Sammi’s Heartfelt Treasures to shop, chat with Michele, and/or make friends with a Bunny (who’s name is Buns BTW). I know I will stop by every time I’m in the area :)”
★★★★★
“An amazing place if you’re in and around Erie looking for gifts/souvenirs. The owner was such a sweet lady, showed us around and the best part about the shop is the house pet - CinnaBunBun. It’s an experience shopping with CinnaBunBun. Highly recommend!”
★★★★★
“Absolutely GORGEOUS jewelry. Lovely layout. BUNBUN the dwarf bunny is a doll but please don't touch him. This is a safe haven and a pleasure every time I walk into the store. My daughters love it as well. Pure energy and good vibes❤️ ask for Shelly she is a saint and willing to be for whom ever needs an ear. We love it here and we love you Shelly”
★★★★★
“So many cute things to look through. A good variety of interesting trinkets, jewelry, art, etc. I will be back so I can take longer to look through everything!”
Good to know
Common questions
What does Sammis Heartfelt Treasures carry?
Sammis Heartfelt Treasures carries Other TCG. Call (814) 897-5978 to check current inventory.
Where is Sammis Heartfelt Treasures located?
Sammis Heartfelt Treasures is at 25 W 9th St in Erie, Pennsylvania 16501.
Within 50 miles
Card shows nearby
Keep browsing
More shops near Erie
ActionToyMan★ 4.7(483)
ActionToyMan is a Erie destination for toys, trading cards, and collectibles, rated 4.7 stars across 483 Google reviews. Open 4 days a week. Located at 1215 W 26th St.
Kinem's Sports Cards★ 4.9(174)
Kinem's Sports Cards is a Erie shop for sports cards and memorabilia, rated 4.9 stars across 174 Google reviews. Open 6 days a week. Located at 3624 Maple St.
Griffons Lair Game Shop: CCG, RPGs & Board Games★ 4.5(129)
Griffons Lair Game Shop: CCG, RPGs & Board Games is a Erie destination for tabletop games and trading cards, rated 4.5 stars across 129 Google reviews. Open 5 days a week. Located at 1651 W 26th St.
Dave's Sport Cards★ 4.2(43)
Dave's Sport Cards is a Erie shop for sports cards and memorabilia, rated 4.2 stars across 43 Google reviews. Open 6 days a week. Located at 4514 Peach St.