Black Gold Sports Cards

2327 Silvernail Rd · Pewaukee, WI 53072

4.7(165)

Black Gold Sports Cards in Pewaukee, Wisconsin

Black Gold Sports Cards is a trading card shop at 2327 Silvernail Rd in Pewaukee, Wisconsin. The shop carries Sports Cards, Pokémon. Store details last verified Monday, August 31, 2026.

Community rating

4.7★

Based on 165 ratings

Be the first local to vote · 4.7 on Google

Great

Rate it

Directions Website (262) 316-0484

Hours

Mon: 10am – 6pm
Tue: 10am – 6pm
Wed: 10am – 8pm
Thu: 10am – 8pm
Fri: 10am – 8pm
Sat: 9am – 5pm
Sun: Closed

Games

Sports Cards
Pokémon

Services

Grading drop-off
League play
Live breaks

Own Black Gold Sports Cards?

Claim this listing to update hours, photos, games, and events. Free.

From Google reviews

What collectors say

★★★★★

“Absolutely outstanding place to consign your cards. My sales guy, Sam, assisted me through the entire process. Sam is professional, honest, quick to reply and thorough. The payment to me was quick easy and more than I expected. I will continue using Black Gold Sports Cards as my exclusive consignment shop. Thank you guys tremendous job. A+!”

Marc Gusto · Google

★★★★★

“Excellent customer service and such friendly people! It was our first time in, and they immediately greeted my daughter with a free Disney pack. It’s those little gestures that truly matter.”

Leng Thao · Google

★

“If you want great customer service and a fun experience I would NOT go here. I went in wanting to trade cards and possibly buy a card there. When I walked in I was hardly noticed and then when someone did finally help me he proceeded to tell me “he doesn’t have time” to look at my trade ins. On top of that the card I was possibly wanting to purchase was for $250 online. When I asked him about that card he proceeds to tell me that he will sell it to me for $300… as I’m standing there IN PERSON ready to buy. The store seems to extremely cater towards online sales rather then in person sales which I understand but based off my experience I’d absolutely take your trade ins to Brew Town cards in greenfield.”

Nathan · Google

★

“Stopped in to pick up a Topps MLB Chrome Mega Pack. Website shows 16 available online, when I asked for them in store I was told "Sorry we broke them all online". Do you want to sell cards? Because I'll never be back. Do better.”

Chris Kraczek · Google

Good to know