Best card shops in Fort Collins, CO
5 shops in Fort Collins + 5 more nearby · sorted by rating · strongest in Other TCG, Magic: The Gathering, Pokémon
Best for Pokémon
The Haunted Game Cafe
★ 4.8 (924)
Best for Sports cards
Diamond Valley Collectibles
★ 4.5 (138)
Best for Magic
Foxfire Games
★ 5.0 (13)
Best for Selling a collection
Heroes and Horrors Games
★ 4.6 (231)
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap
5 shops in Fort Collins
The Toy, Game, and Puzzle Library★ 5.0(23)
The Toy, Game, and Puzzle Library is a Fort Collins destination for toys, trading cards, and collectibles, rated 5.0 stars across 23 Google reviews. Open 4 days a week. Located at 215 E Foothills Pkwy.
Foxfire Games★ 5.0(13)
Foxfire Games is a Fort Collins destination for tabletop games and trading cards, rated 5.0 stars across 13 Google reviews. Open seven days a week. Located at 1228 W Elizabeth St Ste C4 & C5.
Clothes Pony & Dandelion Toys★ 4.8(302)
Clothes Pony & Dandelion Toys is a Fort Collins destination for toys, trading cards, and collectibles, rated 4.8 stars across 302 Google reviews. Open seven days a week. Located at 111 N College Ave.
The Haunted Game Cafe★ 4.8(924)
The Haunted Game Cafe is a Fort Collins destination for tabletop games and trading cards, rated 4.8 stars across 924 Google reviews. Open seven days a week. Located at 3307 S College Ave #107.
Games Ahoy★ 4.5(380)
Games Ahoy is a Fort Collins destination for tabletop games and trading cards, rated 4.5 stars across 380 Google reviews. Open seven days a week. Located at 2721 S College Ave.
5 more within driving distance
The Nerd Store★ 4.6(786)
The Nerd Store is a Fort Collins destination for collectibles and trading cards, rated 4.6 stars across 786 Google reviews. Open 6 days a week. Located at 807 8th St.
Heroes and Horrors Games★ 4.6(231)
Heroes and Horrors Games is a Fort Collins destination for tabletop games and trading cards, rated 4.6 stars across 231 Google reviews. Open 6 days a week. Located at 1215 Main St Ste b.
Diamond Valley Collectibles★ 4.5(138)
Diamond Valley Collectibles is a Fort Collins destination for collectibles and trading cards, rated 4.5 stars across 138 Google reviews. Open seven days a week. Located at 700 Automation Dr Unit C.
Grand Slam Sports Cards-Comic★ 4.3(388)
Grand Slam Sports Cards-Comic is a Fort Collins shop for comics and trading cards, rated 4.3 stars across 388 Google reviews. Open seven days a week. Located at 1730 W Eisenhower Blvd.
Grand Slam Game Center★ 4.1(37)
Grand Slam Game Center is a Fort Collins destination for tabletop games and trading cards, rated 4.1 stars across 37 Google reviews. Open seven days a week. Located at 1718 W Eisenhower Blvd.
At a glance
| Shop | Rating | Games | Buys | Grading |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Toy, Game, and Puzzle Library | ★ 5.0 | TCG | — | — |
| Foxfire Games | ★ 5.0 | TCG, Magic | — | — |
| Clothes Pony & Dandelion Toys | ★ 4.8 | TCG | — | — |
| The Haunted Game Cafe | ★ 4.8 | TCG, Pokémon, Magic | — | — |
| The Nerd StoreGreeley | ★ 4.6 | TCG | — | — |
| Heroes and Horrors GamesWindsor | ★ 4.6 | TCG, Pokémon, Magic | Yes | — |
| Games Ahoy | ★ 4.5 | TCG | — | — |
| Diamond Valley CollectiblesWindsor | ★ 4.5 | TCG, Pokémon, One Piece | Yes | Drop-off |
| Grand Slam Sports Cards-ComicLoveland | ★ 4.3 | Sports | — | — |
| Grand Slam Game CenterLoveland | ★ 4.1 | TCG | — | — |
Within 50 miles
Card shows near Fort Collins
Card & Collector Show by NoCo Collector Con — Fort Collins (Saturday,
The Drake Centre · Fort Collins, CO · 2 mi
Northern Colorado Cards and Collectibles Expo
The Drake Centre · Fort Collins, CO · 2 mi
RetroMania Collectibles Show
Boulder County Fairgrounds Exhibit Building · Longmont, CO · 30 mi
Wyoming Card and Collectables Show
Eagles Club Post #128 · Cheyenne, WY · 40 mi
Keep exploring
Nearby cities
Good to know
FAQ
How many card shops are near Fort Collins, CO?
There are 10 card shops in and around Fort Collins, Colorado listed on CardsNearby, carrying Other TCG, Magic: The Gathering, Pokémon and more.
Where can I sell cards in Fort Collins?
2 of the 10 card shops in Fort Collins run an active buylist and buy collections, including Heroes and Horrors Games and Diamond Valley Collectibles. Call ahead for large collections.
Are there card shows near Fort Collins?
Yes — 4 card shows run within 50 miles of Fort Collins, including Card & Collector Show by NoCo Collector Con — Fort Collins (Saturday,. See each show page for upcoming dates.