5 best MTG card shops in Fort Collins, CO
5 shops in and around Fort Collins carry Magic: The Gathering — singles walls, sealed product, and in many cases Commander nights and Friday Night Magic. Listings note league and event play where we've confirmed it.
Ranked by magic: the gathering shops-weighted CardsNearby Score · Last verified Sunday, November 8, 2026 · methodology · report a correction
| Shop | Rating | Singles | Buys | League | Distance |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Haunted Game Cafe | ★ 4.8 | Yes | — | — | 3.0 mi |
| Foxfire Games | ★ 5.0 | Yes | — | Yes | 1.0 mi |
| The Toy, Game, and Puzzle Library | ★ 5.0 | — | — | Yes | 3.0 mi |
| Games Ahoy | ★ 4.5 | — | — | — | 2.5 mi |
| Wolfs Tale Games | ★ 5.0 | — | — | — | 12.6 mi |
The Haunted Game Cafe★ 4.8(924)
TCG, Pokémon, Magic, Singles, Supplies
Foxfire Games★ 5.0(13)
TCG, Magic, Pokémon, League play, Singles
The Toy, Game, and Puzzle Library★ 5.0(23)
TCG, Magic, League play
Games Ahoy★ 4.5(380)
TCG, Pokémon, Magic
Wolfs Tale Games★ 5.0(7)
Magic, Pokémon
Within 30 miles
Worth the drive
- Heroes and Horrors Games · Windsor · 11 mi
- Grand Slam Sports Cards-Comic · Loveland · 12 mi
- Grand Slam Game Center · Loveland · 12 mi
- The Nerd Store · Greeley · 23 mi
- Excalibur Cards & Games · Longmont · 27 mi
- Atomic Goblin Games · Longmont · 28 mi
Good to know
FAQ
Magic: The Gathering shops near Fort Collins, CO — how many options are there?
5 shops near Fort Collins, Colorado carrying Magic: The Gathering — Commander and Standard singles, sealed product, and play nights, with hours and details.
Which is the highest-rated option near Fort Collins?
The Toy, Game, and Puzzle Library has the highest displayed public rating at 5.0 stars across 23 reviews. Our list is ordered by a magic: the gathering shops-weighted CardsNearby Score, which also factors verified services and data completeness — see the methodology.
Browse all card shops near Fort Collins or the national magic: the gathering shops directory.