Vintage Indy Sports

1450 N Main St Ste B · Indianapolis, IN 46224

4.9(33)

Vintage Indy Sports in Indianapolis, Indiana

Vintage Indy Sports is a trading card shop at 1450 N Main St Ste B in Indianapolis, Indiana. The shop carries Sports Cards. Store details last verified Monday, August 31, 2026.

Address: 1450 N Main St Ste B, Indianapolis, IN, 46224
Phone: (317) 910-7650
Games: Sports Cards
Services: Call to confirm
Rating: ★ 4.9 (33)
Verified: Monday, August 31, 2026

Community rating

4.9★

Based on 33 ratings

Be the first local to vote · 4.9 on Google

Beloved

Rate it

Directions Website (317) 910-7650

Hours of operation

Mon: 10am – 5pm
Tue: 10am – 5pm
Wed: 10am – 5pm
Thu: 10am – 5pm
Fri: 10am – 5pm
Sat: 10am – 5pm
Sun: Closed

Games carried

Sports Cards

Services

Not verified yet — buylist, grading drop-off, and event details vary by shop.

Own Vintage Indy Sports?

Claim this listing to update hours, photos, games, and events — and put the “Find us on CardsNearby” badge on your site. Free.

From Google reviews

What collectors say

★★★★★

“I have been to the shop twice now after a recommendation from my brother in law. I was not disappointed! Scott is awesome to talk to and knows his stuff. They have always made me feel welcome and never minded how long I hung out to look for cards or the questions I had. Prices are absolutely more than fair. Can't recommend them enough!”

Ashley Marcoux · Google

★★★★★

“Love Vintage Indy Sports!! A true local gem, this place is a MUST SEE! The customer service is second to none. I needed help with my first over and I was so well cared for. On my second order, I made an error and Vintage Indy Sports helped me fix my issue. They did not have to do that. This is a destination. Don’t wait until you’re in in area. If you love sports, memorabilia, or are just a HOOSIER at heart, get on over there now!”

Jennifer Pappe · Google

★★★★★

“This is the best memorabilia shop in the state! Incredible collection and diverse selection of collectibles to museum-worthy items! Great selection of modern and vintage sports cards! Scott is the best in the business!”

Josh Heideman · Google

★★★★★

“Easily the best sports memorabilia store in Indiana. I wish I could keep this as my own secret, but Scott deserves the recognition for what he has created.”

DJ Eckert · Google

Good to know