Best card shops in Indianapolis, IN

24 shops · sorted by rating · strongest in Other TCG, Magic: The Gathering, Pokémon

CardsNearby tracks verified card shops across Indianapolis — a dedicated sports-card exchange, buylist-heavy game stores, and multiple grading drop-off points — compared by specialty, services, hours, and upcoming local shows.

Last verified Tuesday, September 1, 2026

Best for Pokémon

Paradigm Games

★ 4.7 (130)

Best for Sports cards

Indy Card Exchange

★ 4.7 (390)

Best for Magic

Paradigm Games

★ 4.7 (130)

Best for Selling a collection

Paradigm Games

★ 4.7 (130)

Sell your cards →Card grading →Pokémon shops →Sports card shops →

9 Pokémon card vending machines in Indianapolis →

24 shops

Sorted by CardsNearby Score

Paradigm Games★ 4.7(130)

TCG, Pokémon, Magic, Buylist, League play

Paradigm Games carries tabletop games and trading cards in Indianapolis, IN. Open 6 days a week at 2479 N Meridian St.

TCGPokémonMagicBuylistLeague play

2.4 mi

Game World★ 4.8(303)

TCG, Pokémon, Magic, Buylist, Singles

Game World carries tabletop games and trading cards in Indianapolis, IN. Open seven days a week at 7625 Shelby St.

TCGPokémonMagicBuylistSingles

7.9 mi

Gray Gauntlet Games★ 4.7(91)

TCG, Pokémon, Magic, Buylist, League play

Gray Gauntlet Games carries tabletop games and trading cards in Indianapolis, IN. Open 5 days a week at 7998 Centerpoint Dr Ste 750.

TCGPokémonMagicBuylistLeague play

13.7 mi

Mage's Comics and Games★ 4.8(200)

TCG, Pokémon, Magic, Grading drop-off, League play

Mage's Comics and Games carries comics and trading cards in Indianapolis, IN. Open seven days a week at 7623 Shelby St.

TCGPokémonMagicGrading drop-offLeague play

7.8 mi

Family Time Games★ 4.8(820)

TCG, Pokémon, Magic, League play, Supplies

Family Time Games carries tabletop games and trading cards in Indianapolis, IN. Open seven days a week at 8796 Michigan Rd.

TCGPokémonMagicLeague playSupplies

10.7 mi

Saltire Toys & Games★ 4.7(329)

TCG, Pokémon, Magic, League play, Supplies

Saltire Toys & Games carries tabletop games and trading cards in Indianapolis, IN. Open seven days a week at 11135 Pendleton Pike Ste 1200.

TCGPokémonMagicLeague playSupplies

11.9 mi

Elf 'N Moon Gaming & Hobby★ 4.9(293)

TCG, One Piece, League play, Supplies

Elf 'N Moon Gaming & Hobby carries cards and collectibles in Indianapolis, IN. Open seven days a week at 1354 Shelby St Ste A.

TCGOne PieceLeague playSupplies

1.7 mi

Game Preserve★ 4.7(706)

TCG, Magic, League play

Game Preserve carries tabletop games and trading cards in Indianapolis, IN. Open seven days a week at 1551 E Stop 12 Rd.

TCGMagicLeague play

8.8 mi

Indy Card Exchange★ 4.7(390)

Sports, Buylist, Grading drop-off

Indy Card Exchange carries cards and collectibles in Indianapolis, IN. Open 6 days a week at 7035 E 96th St Ste p.

SportsBuylistGrading drop-off

12.5 mi

The Toy Pit★ 4.8(1618)

TCG, Buylist

The Toy Pit carries cards and collectibles in Indianapolis, IN. Open 6 days a week at 3827 N College Ave.

TCGBuylist

4.0 mi

Indy Card Shop★ 4.6(29)

Pokémon, Magic, Yu-Gi-Oh!, Singles

Indy Card Shop carries cards and collectibles in Indianapolis, IN. Open seven days a week at 2346 S Lynhurst Dr #706.

PokémonMagicYu-Gi-Oh!Singles

5.5 mi

Game Time★ 4.2(396)

TCG, Pokémon, Magic, League play, Supplies

Game Time carries tabletop games and trading cards in Indianapolis, IN. Open 6 days a week at 8244 Center Run Dr.

TCGPokémonMagicLeague playSupplies

10.9 mi

The Game Preserve★ 4.7(432)

TCG

The Game Preserve carries tabletop games and trading cards in Indianapolis, IN. Open seven days a week at 8487 Union Chapel Rd Ste 660.

TCG

10.1 mi

Comic Carnival★ 4.7(375)

TCG

Comic Carnival carries comics and trading cards in Indianapolis, IN. Open seven days a week at 7235 N Keystone Ave Ste e.

TCG

8.4 mi

Good Games Indianapolis★ 4.6(480)

TCG

Good Games Indianapolis carries tabletop games and trading cards in Indianapolis, IN. Open seven days a week at 111 S Meridian St.

TCG

0.2 mi

Downtown Comics★ 4.4(316)

TCG, Grading drop-off, Supplies

Downtown Comics carries comics and trading cards in Indianapolis, IN. Open seven days a week at 11 E Market St.

TCGGrading drop-offSupplies

0.1 mi

Downtown Comics In Castleton★ 4.4(290)

TCG, Grading drop-off, Supplies

Downtown Comics In Castleton carries comics and trading cards in Indianapolis, IN. Open seven days a week at 5767 E 86th St.

TCGGrading drop-offSupplies

11.0 mi

Collectors Emporium★ 4.7(165)

TCG

Collectors Emporium carries trading card games and collectibles in Indianapolis, IN.

TCG

21.0 mi

Vintage Indy Sports★ 4.9(33)

Sports

Vintage Indy Sports carries sports cards and memorabilia in Indianapolis, IN.

Sports

4.6 mi

Grandmaster Games★ 4.3(596)

TCG

Grandmaster Games carries tabletop games and trading cards in Indianapolis, IN. Open seven days a week at 4200 S East St Ste 20.

TCG

4.5 mi

ComicsPriceGuide★ 4.9(15)

TCG

ComicsPriceGuide carries comics and trading cards in Indianapolis, IN. Open 5 days a week at 212 W 10th St # A470.

TCG

0.9 mi

Raven's Comics, Collectibles & Books★ 4.7(53)

TCG

Raven's Comics, Collectibles & Books carries comics and trading cards in Indianapolis, IN. Open 5 days a week at 2016 E Southport Rd #1.

TCG

7.4 mi

Collectors Paradise★ 4.5(70)

TCG

Collectors Paradise carries trading card games and collectibles in Indianapolis, IN.

TCG

4.6 mi

The Card Depot★ 4.5(31)

The Card Depot carries cards and collectibles in Indianapolis, IN. Open 6 days a week at 1083 E Hanna Ave.

4.3 mi

Which Indianapolis card shop fits your need

If you want…	Go to
Sports cards	Indy Card Exchange
Selling a collection	Indy Card Exchange, The Toy Pit, Game World
Grading drop-off	Indy Card Exchange, Mage's Comics and Games, Downtown Comics
Pokémon cards	Family Time Games, Game World
Organized play	Family Time Games, Game Preserve

The shops, in detail

Indy Card Exchange — the sports institution

★ 4.7 (390 Google reviews) · 7035 E 96th St Ste p

Indianapolis's dedicated sports-card exchange — singles, an active buylist, and grading drop-off. The first call for buying or selling sports cards anywhere in central Indiana.

The Toy Pit — the most-reviewed buyer

★ 4.8 (1618 Google reviews) · 3827 N College Ave

One of the city's most-reviewed collectible stores, with trading cards in the mix and an active buying counter.

Family Time Games — the play hub

★ 4.8 (820 Google reviews) · 8796 Michigan Rd

Pokémon and Magic with a big organized-play space and one of the busiest event calendars in the metro.

Game World — TCG buylist depth

★ 4.8 (303 Google reviews) · 7625 Shelby St

Pokémon, Magic, and Yu-Gi-Oh! singles with a buylist — a dependable stop for moving TCG inventory in either direction.

Mage's Comics — services under one roof

★ 4.8 (200 Google reviews) · 7623 Shelby St

Pokémon, Magic, One Piece, and Lorcana with grading drop-off and league play — the most service-complete TCG stop in the city.

Elf 'n Moon — the One Piece specialist

★ 4.9 (293 Google reviews) · 1354 Shelby St Ste A

A highly-rated newer shop with One Piece at the center, plus organized play and supplies.

At a glance

Shop	Rating	Games	Buys	Grading
Paradigm Games	★ 4.7	TCG, Pokémon, Magic	Yes	—
Game World	★ 4.8	TCG, Pokémon, Magic	Yes	—
Gray Gauntlet Games	★ 4.7	TCG, Pokémon, Magic	Yes	—
Mage's Comics and Games	★ 4.8	TCG, Pokémon, Magic	—	Drop-off
Family Time Games	★ 4.8	TCG, Pokémon, Magic	—	—
Saltire Toys & Games	★ 4.7	TCG, Pokémon, Magic	—	—
Elf 'N Moon Gaming & Hobby	★ 4.9	TCG, One Piece	—	—
Game Preserve	★ 4.7	TCG, Magic	—	—
Indy Card Exchange	★ 4.7	Sports	Yes	Drop-off
The Toy Pit	★ 4.8	TCG	Yes	—