CardsNearby

11 best MTG card shops in Indianapolis, IN

11 shops in and around Indianapolis carry Magic: The Gathering — singles walls, sealed product, and in many cases Commander nights and Friday Night Magic. Listings note league and event play where we've confirmed it.

Ranked by magic: the gathering shops-weighted CardsNearby Score · Last verified Sunday, November 8, 2026 · methodology · report a correction

ShopRatingSinglesBuysLeagueDistance
Paradigm Games★ 4.7YesYesYes2.4 mi
Gray Gauntlet Games★ 4.7YesYesYes13.7 mi
Game World★ 4.8YesYes—7.9 mi
Mage's Comics and Games★ 4.8——Yes7.8 mi
Family Time Games★ 4.8——Yes10.7 mi
Game Preserve★ 4.7——Yes8.8 mi
Saltire Toys & Games★ 4.7——Yes11.9 mi
Indy Card Shop★ 4.6Yes——5.5 mi
The Game Preserve★ 4.7———10.1 mi
Game Time★ 4.2——Yes10.9 mi
PG

Paradigm Games★ 4.7(130)

TCG, Pokémon, Magic, Buylist, League play

2.4 mi
GG

Gray Gauntlet Games★ 4.7(91)

TCG, Pokémon, Magic, Buylist, League play

13.7 mi
GW

Game World★ 4.8(303)

TCG, Pokémon, Magic, Buylist, Singles

7.9 mi
MC

Mage's Comics and Games★ 4.8(200)

TCG, Pokémon, Magic, Grading drop-off, League play

7.8 mi
FT

Family Time Games★ 4.8(820)

TCG, Pokémon, Magic, League play, Supplies

10.7 mi
GP

Game Preserve★ 4.7(706)

TCG, Magic, League play

8.8 mi
ST

Saltire Toys & Games★ 4.7(329)

TCG, Pokémon, Magic, League play, Supplies

11.9 mi
IC

Indy Card Shop★ 4.6(29)

Pokémon, Magic, Yu-Gi-Oh!, Singles

5.5 mi
TG

The Game Preserve★ 4.7(432)

TCG, Magic

10.1 mi
GT

Game Time★ 4.2(396)

TCG, Pokémon, Magic, League play, Supplies

10.9 mi
L

Laughtail★ 5.0(4)

Pokémon, Magic, One Piece

21.7 mi

Within 30 miles

Worth the drive

Good to know

FAQ

Magic: The Gathering shops near Indianapolis, IN — how many options are there?

11 shops near Indianapolis, Indiana carrying Magic: The Gathering — Commander and Standard singles, sealed product, and play nights, with hours and details.

Which is the highest-rated option near Indianapolis?

Laughtail has the highest displayed public rating at 5.0 stars across 4 reviews. Our list is ordered by a magic: the gathering shops-weighted CardsNearby Score, which also factors verified services and data completeness — see the methodology.

Browse all card shops near Indianapolis or the national magic: the gathering shops directory.