Downtown Comics In Castleton

5767 E 86th St · Indianapolis, IN 46250

4.4(290)

Downtown Comics In Castleton in Indianapolis, Indiana

Downtown Comics In Castleton is a trading card shop at 5767 E 86th St in Indianapolis, Indiana. The shop carries Other TCG. Store details last verified Tuesday, September 1, 2026.

Address: 5767 E 86th St, Indianapolis, IN, 46250
Phone: (317) 845-9991
Games: Other TCG
Services: Grading drop-off, Supplies
Rating: ★ 4.4 (290)
Verified: Tuesday, September 1, 2026

Community rating

4.4★

Based on 290 ratings

Be the first local to vote · 4.4 on Google

Solid

Rate it

Directions Website (317) 845-9991

Hours of operation

Mon: 11am – 6pm
Tue: 11am – 6pm
Wed: 11am – 8pm
Thu: 11am – 8pm
Fri: 11am – 8pm
Sat: 11am – 8pm
Sun: 11am – 4pm

Games carried

Other TCG

Services

Grading drop-off
Supplies

Own Downtown Comics In Castleton?

Claim this listing to update hours, photos, games, and events — and put the “Find us on CardsNearby” badge on your site. Free.

From Google reviews

What collectors say

★★★★★

“Had a great experience at Downtown Comics in Castleton for Free comic book Day. Friendly people, activities for the kids and even saw the Ghost Busters. Thank you Downtown Comics”

Alaska Girl · Google

★★★★★

“Coming here every Wednesday to get my new books is always the highlight of my week. Both this and the downtown location (only two I've ever visited) are great, and the staff are always polite and fun to talk to. Downtown Comics is easily the best comic book store in Indy.”

Katherine Klamer · Google

★★★★★

“Downtown Comics has been a family favorite for years! They’re always so kind and helpful. Their selection is great. An amazing comic store that caters to all ages.”

Damaris Sanchez · Google

★★★★★

“Wonderful service from the employee. She was a joy to talk to and offered me multiple recommendations. I felt extremely welcome and it does not go without notice. Much appreciation for this visit on the evening of 4/24/26.”

Jason Eger · Google

Good to know