Best card shops in Staten Island, NJ

2 shops · sorted by rating · strongest in Sports Cards, Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering

Best for Pokémon

TheIslandTCG

★ 5.0 (49)

Best for Sports cards

TheIslandTCG

★ 5.0 (49)

Best for Magic

TheIslandTCG

★ 5.0 (49)

2 shops

Sorted by CardsNearby Score

TheIslandTCG★ 5.0(49)

Pokémon, Magic, One Piece, League play, Singles

TheIslandTCG carries trading card games and singles in Staten Island, NJ. Open 6 days a week at 8 Johnson St Unit 1.

PokémonMagicOne PieceLeague playSingles

1.2 mi

Jam Sports Cards & Collectibles★ 4.2(145)

Sports

Jam Sports Cards & Collectibles carries sports cards and memorabilia in Staten Island, NJ. Open seven days a week at 7309 Amboy Rd.

Sports

1.2 mi

At a glance

Shop	Rating	Games	Buys	Grading
TheIslandTCG	★ 5.0	Pokémon, Magic, One Piece	—	—
Jam Sports Cards & Collectibles	★ 4.2	Sports	—	—

More shops within 25 miles

Epic Trading Collectibles · Woodbridge · 4 mi
Illustrious Cards and Games LLC · Fords · 5 mi
Paul's Toy Room - Toys, Collectables, Gaming, Warhammer, & Hobby Supplies · Parlin · 5 mi
True Believers Gaming & Collectibles · Edison · 5 mi
Ragingeek Comics & Toys · Metuchen · 7 mi
Collectibles NJ · Metuchen · 7 mi
the geekery · Matawan · 8 mi
J2Games.com · Clark · 8 mi
Attack of the Baseball Cards · Clark · 8 mi
L's Collection TCG & Games · Edison · 9 mi
Rogue Comics & Collectibles · Cranford · 10 mi
Downtown Cards & Collectibles · Highland Park · 10 mi

2 shops in view

Within 50 miles

Card shows near Staten Island

All shows near here →

Sat5Sep

Woodbridge Card Show

Woodbridge Center · Woodbridge, NJ · 4 mi

SportsPokémonOne Piece+1

Monthly

Apex TCG Card Show

Sheraton Edison · Edison, NJ · 5 mi

Sports

Recurring NJ area tour

Friday Night Sports Card & Pokemon Show

St. Patricks School · Staten Island, NY · 6 mi

Sports

recurring every 4 6 weeks

Fri30Oct

Dallas Card Show New Jersey

New Jersey Convention and Expo Center · Edison, NJ · 6 mi

SportsPokémonTCG+1

Annual

Keep exploring

Nearby cities

Woodbridge

1 shop · 3 mi

Fords

1 shop · 5 mi

Parlin

1 shop · 5 mi

Metuchen

2 shops · 7 mi

Good to know

FAQ

How many card shops are near Staten Island, NJ?

There are 2 card shops in and around Staten Island, New Jersey listed on CardsNearby, carrying Sports Cards, Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering and more.

Where can I sell cards in Staten Island?

Several shops in and around Staten Island buy collections — check each listing's services, or visit a nearby card show where dozens of buyers set up.

Are there card shows near Staten Island?

Yes — 38 card shows run within 50 miles of Staten Island, including Woodbridge Card Show. See each show page for upcoming dates.