Southpaw Sports Cards
8342 Brewerton Rd · Cicero, NY 13039

Southpaw Sports Cards is a trading card shop at 8342 Brewerton Rd in Cicero, New York. The shop carries Sports Cards. Store details last verified Monday, August 31, 2026.
Community rating
4.4★
Based on 149 ratings
Be the first local to vote · 4.4 on Google
Solid
Rate it
Hours
- Mon
- 11am – 6pm
- Tue
- 11am – 6pm
- Wed
- 11am – 6pm
- Thu
- 11am – 6pm
- Fri
- 11am – 6pm
- Sat
- 11am – 5pm
- Sun
- Closed
Games
- Sports Cards
Services
Not verified yet — buylist, grading drop-off, and event details vary by shop.
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap
Own Southpaw Sports Cards?
Claim this listing to update hours, photos, games, and events. Free.
From Google reviews
What collectors say
★★★★★
“Just stopped in and decided to buy the last 7 packs of Donruss and I can't believe the pulls i got. I've always enjoyed shopping there and this just increased my experience.”
★★★★★
“I’m from out of town and was visiting family. My brother-in-law and I wanted to swing over and I had stuff to trade. The owner was super cool and yes, he buys at “50% comp” but tells you right off the bat. I also found he was pretty generous, but these guys gotta make money too! I actually can’t wait to go back, he was a great guy to deal with. Got a nice tin of Upper Deck golf, some football and my BIL picked up a nice Hank Aaron auto!”
★★★★★
“I have been going to Southpaw Sports Cards for over 20 years. Always love to go there. It's a small store but has a lot of cards! The owner Mark has mostly been the person I have talked to. Always friendly. A lot of the time, Mark is the only one there but would always help me out even while busy with stocking his merchandise, taking inventory or even for a quick question while helpoing someone else. The store has a lot of different collectable products which I like. Some cool old wax stuff which is fun to open too. I met Brian a while ago and he was great to talk to also. I have always had a good experience over a very long time of being a customer of Southpaw Sports Cards. You know, sometimes, in retail, the job can be hectic due to a number of things. I would think it would be tough to own a retail store, or any business with a limited amount of employees and a limited amount of time open to the public. Mark and Brian do a great job at Southpaw. I know they care about their customers. I look forward to my next visit there soon.”
★★★★★
“I deal with Mark and Carl. Both are extremely knowledgeable and easy to deal with. I look forward to doing alot more business with Southpaw. I would recommend them to anyone, whether new collector or vet collector.”
Good to know
Common questions
What does Southpaw Sports Cards carry?
Southpaw Sports Cards carries Sports Cards. Call (315) 699-1579 to check current inventory.
Where is Southpaw Sports Cards located?
Southpaw Sports Cards is at 8342 Brewerton Rd in Cicero, New York 13039.
Keep browsing
More shops near Cicero
Dame Games★ 4.9(25)
Dame Games carries tabletop games and trading cards in North Syracuse, NY. Open 5 days a week at 201 S Main St.
Collectibles Galore★ 4.8(125)
Collectibles Galore carries cards and collectibles in North Syracuse, NY. Open 3 days a week at 615 S Main St.
Microgame★ 4.6(297)
Microgame carries tabletop games and trading cards in Clay, NY. Open seven days a week at 4160 NY-31 Ste 300.
GG Cards & Breaks★ 4.6(84)
GG Cards & Breaks carries sports cards and memorabilia in Syracuse, NY. Open 6 days a week at 639 Delmar Pl.