Card shops in New York
140 qualifying card shops across 55 New York municipalities, organized into 55 metro-area directories — strongest in Other TCG, Pokémon, Sports Cards. Each listing has hours, games carried, and services like buylists and grading drop-off.
Data last refreshed Thursday, October 15, 2026. CardsNearby includes physical card and hobby stores with posted hours and an established review history; store hours, ratings and services are refreshed approximately every 30 days. See our methodology or report a correction.
Rochester
20 shops
New York
14 shops
Brooklyn
13 shops
Buffalo
11 shops
Albany
10 shops
Syracuse
7 shops
Long Island City
4 shops
Webster
4 shops
Depew
3 shops
Tonawanda
3 shops
North Syracuse
2 shops
Astoria
2 shops
Troy
2 shops
Cheektowaga
2 shops
North Tonawanda
2 shops
Williamsville
2 shops
Staten Island
1 shop
Schenectady
1 shop
Saratoga Springs
1 shop
Johnstown
1 shop
Mechanicville
1 shop
Scarsdale
1 shop
Manlius
1 shop
Le Roy
1 shop
Forest Hills
1 shop
West Seneca
1 shop
Mineola
1 shop
Corona
1 shop
Spencerport
1 shop
Liverpool
1 shop
Hamburg
1 shop
Canastota
1 shop
Baldwinsville
1 shop
Ridgewood
1 shop
Blasdell
1 shop
Brockport
1 shop
East Amherst
1 shop
Averill Park
1 shop
Tonawanda Town
1 shop
Colonie
1 shop
Amsterdam
1 shop
East Aurora
1 shop
Middle Village
1 shop
Pulaski
1 shop
Orchard Park
1 shop
Kenmore
1 shop
Clifton Park
1 shop
Elmont
1 shop
Glenmont
1 shop
Glens Falls
1 shop
Cicero
1 shop
Fulton
1 shop
Phelps
1 shop
Clay
1 shop
Oneida
1 shop
Highest rated
Top card shops in New York
| Shop | City | Google rating | Games | Buys |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Just Games Rochester | Rochester | ★ 4.9 (651) | TCG, Magic, Lorcana | Yes |
| Millennium Games | Rochester | ★ 4.7 (2887) | TCG, Pokémon, Magic | Yes |
| Legacy Games | Webster | ★ 4.9 (184) | TCG, Pokémon, Magic | Yes |
| Midtown Comics Times Square | New York | ★ 4.6 (9693) | TCG, One Piece, Sports | Yes |
| Midtown Comics Grand Central | New York | ★ 4.6 (2178) | TCG, One Piece, Sports | Yes |
| Major Sports Cards | Mineola | ★ 5.0 (219) | Sports, Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh! | — |
| Midtown Comics Astoria Outlet | Astoria | ★ 4.6 (157) | TCG, One Piece, Sports | Yes |
| Dio’s Treasures | Le Roy | ★ 4.9 (89) | TCG, Pokémon, Magic | — |
| Hobby Spirit | Williamsville | ★ 5.0 (62) | TCG, Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh! | — |
| Heart Of The Game | Buffalo | ★ 4.4 (591) | TCG, Pokémon, Magic | Yes |
| Bard and Baker Board Game Cafe | Troy | ★ 4.8 (591) | TCG, Pokémon, Magic | — |
| WeTheHobby | Rochester | ★ 4.8 (507) | TCG, Sports | Yes |
| Kingpin Comics & Gaming | Tonawanda | ★ 4.8 (207) | TCG, Pokémon, Magic | Yes |
| Comic Book Station | Brooklyn | ★ 4.7 (111) | TCG, Pokémon, Sports | Yes |
| Hammergirl Anime | Rochester | ★ 4.6 (488) | TCG, Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh! | — |
Complete directory
Every listed shop, by city
Rochester area
- Just Games Rochester
- Millennium Games
- WeTheHobby
- Hammergirl Anime
- 13th Verse Comics
- LingSter Games
- Wonderland Comics
- Rhino's Comics & Collectibles
- 1stplayervideogametruck
- Comics Etc.
- All Heroes Comics
- 1st Print Comics
- Leone’s Collectibles
- Treasure Hunt of Rochester
- Dice Versa
- The Game Cave
- Comic Book Heaven
- Game On!!
- Endzone Collectibles
- Yankee Clipper House of Cards
By specialty
Specialty guides
The best card shops in New York, ranked →
Events
Card shows in New York
Albany Sports Card, Memorabilia & TCG Show
Polish Community Center · Albany, NY
Northtowns Card & Memorabilia Show
American Legion Post, 6525 Ward Rd · Sanborn, NY
Collectorsfest Sports, Memorabilia & TCG Collectible Show
NYS Fairgrounds - Science & Industry Building · Syracuse, NY
CollectorFest Monthly
Louis S. Wolk JCC of Greater Rochester · Rochester, NY
Good to know
FAQ
How many card shops are in New York?
CardsNearby lists 140 qualifying card shops across 55 New York municipalities, organized into 55 metro-area directories. Listings are physical sports card shops and trading card game (TCG) stores with posted hours and an established review history.
Which New York stores sell trading card games (TCG)?
111 of the 140 listed New York shops are TCG stores carrying Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh!, or other trading card games — including Just Games Rochester and Millennium Games. Filter any city page by game to find TCG stores near you.
Which New York city has the most card shops?
Rochester has the most listings, with 20 shops in and around the city.
Where can I sell cards in New York?
22 of the 140 New York shops listed run an active buylist or buy collections, including Dame Games and Leone’s Collectibles. Check each listing's services and call ahead for large collections.
Are there card shows in New York?
Yes — 30 recurring card shows are listed in New York. See the New York show calendar for upcoming dates, venues and admission.