The Game Cave
3824 Dewey Ave · Rochester, NY 14616
The Game Cave is a trading card shop at 3824 Dewey Ave in Rochester, New York. The shop carries Other TCG. Store details last verified Monday, August 31, 2026.
- Address
- 3824 Dewey Ave, Rochester, NY, 14616
- Phone
- (585) 685-8004
- Games
- Other TCG
- Services
- Call to confirm
- Rating
- ★ 4.4 (72)
- Verified
- Monday, August 31, 2026
Community rating
4.4★
Based on 72 ratings
Be the first local to vote · 4.4 on Google
Solid
Rate it
Hours of operation
- Mon
- Closed
- Tue
- 6pm – 9pm
- Wed
- 1pm – 9pm
- Thu
- 1pm – 9pm
- Fri
- 1pm – 9pm
- Sat
- 12pm – 7pm
- Sun
- 12pm – 7pm
Games carried
- Other TCG
Services
Not verified yet — buylist, grading drop-off, and event details vary by shop.
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap
Own The Game Cave?
Claim this listing to update hours, photos, games, and events — and put the “Find us on CardsNearby” badge on your site. Free.
From Google reviews
What collectors say
★★★★★
“I have been 3 times now and the price has always been more than fair. Found the employee who assisted me all three times to be competent, quick, and courteous. Very appreciative to have another card shop in the area and wish them the best”
★★★
“PSA, BE CAREFUL! Seems like an honest guy and seems to know his retail business well however lacks an understanding for private sale value of pokemon. Brought in my neat collection of over 1,000 cards vintage 1999-2010 and he looked through them for 5 minutes pulled out 7 cards and gave me a fair offer but then told me the rest he didnt want and werent worth more than $50 for all because of condition etc.. I listed that entire set the very next day on marketplace and sold them for $700 and probably could have got more considering within 5 minutes of posting the listing I got 15 messages.”
★★
“Went in to the store with no knowledge of Pokemon. I wanted to sell a bunch of PSA graded cards I had just aquired. Worker didnt even pick one up. He ended up looking at some raw cards I had and picked 3 of them he was interested in. The first 2 cards were of minimal value. The last one (Charizard EX in great condition) was worth a decent amount of money. I was offered 160 for the 3 cards, which I thought was fair and I believed the worker to be telling the truth. I get home and check the exact card I had just sold to him and it was triple the amount and got boned. CHECK THE VALUE OF YOUR CARDS BEFORE BRINGING THEM IN TO SELL. Very disappointed to be taken advantage of.”
★
“This shop sells pokemon cards at scalper prices ($9 a pack) And one time when I went I told another customer that based on the market price of the card she was trying to sell it was pretty fair price she got from the employee, and the employee must not have heard me right since he said in a pretty agressive/rude voice to not undercut him or something like that. Either way not a pleasent experience especially since I wasnt even an adult then. Probably best to avoid this store due to scalper prices and rudeness.”
Good to know
Common questions
What does The Game Cave carry?
The Game Cave carries Other TCG. Call (585) 685-8004 to check current inventory.
Where is The Game Cave located?
The Game Cave is at 3824 Dewey Ave in Rochester, New York 14616.
Within 50 miles
Card shows nearby
Keep browsing