TCGLegit

5857 Transit Rd · East Amherst, NY 14051

5.0(61)

TCGLegit is a trading card shop at 5857 Transit Rd in East Amherst, New York. The shop carries Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Lorcana, One Piece, Other TCG. Store details last verified Monday, August 31, 2026.

Community rating

5.0★

Based on 61 ratings

Be the first local to vote · 5.0 on Google

Beloved

Rate it

Directions Website (716) 458-0041

Hours

Mon: 12pm – 7pm
Tue: 12pm – 7pm
Wed: 12pm – 7pm
Thu: 12pm – 7pm
Fri: 12pm – 7pm
Sat: 12pm – 4pm
Sun: Closed

Games

Pokémon
Magic: The Gathering
Lorcana
One Piece
Other TCG

Services

Not verified yet — buylist, grading drop-off, and event details vary by shop.

Own TCGLegit?

Claim this listing to update hours, photos, games, and events. Free.

From Google reviews

What collectors say

★★★★★

“Great friendly local shop. Always nice to stop in and see what’s in the display or to chat with Joel. They have a wide selection from sealed to singles to slabs so there’s something for everyone. Their pricing is super fair and they always work with you to figure something out. They do a lot for their community in giveaways, grading submissions, play nights, streams, etc. I picked up this PC ETB on release week from them. I would recommend this shop to anyone interested in TCGs.”

Shuya Huang · Google

★★★★★

“My wife and I got into Pokemon cards in the summer of 2025 and needed a local card shop that would support our hobby. Little did we know we would not only find one, but a whole community as well! TCGLegit is an amazing family owned and run store that provides the stock and services we need to grow our collection, but they have a wonderful community of patrons that make shopping here infinitely more enjoyable. Love this store!”

Eric Weiss · Google

★★★★★

“Joel and Melissa run an awesome, family and oriented shop in the area. Very knowledgeable and helpful! Better people than shop owners and that’s saying a lot, cause it’s an awesome shop! Also you get GREAT pulls from there too!”

Patrick Faracca · Google

★★★★★

“Been coming here since a little after it opened a year ago and have honestly never had a bad experience. Owners Joel and Melissa always welcome you with open arms and treat you like family. They’re always happy to help you and they are super transparent about the operations. Selection of cards and sealed product is great. Events are always a ton of fun. Overall super friendly shop and community, I highly recommend anyone of any TCG to stop by.”

Jai 492 · Google

Good to know