American Legends

★★★★★

“I can't say enough about what a great store this is. The owners are some of the nicest people you will ever meet. They are one of the rare ones that have been around the hobby forever and has been able to evolve to what it has become. A beautiful store and a great group of people running it.”

★★★★★

“I've driven past this place for years and went in for the first time today. I was immediately welcomed with warm energy and received very honest/professional advice regarding a card set we own. I ended up purchasing my first pack (2025-26 Topps Chrome®) since I was a kid. I will definitely return.”

★★★★★

“This is a beautifully designed space with gems of unique and fundamental important NY Sports scene tied memorabilia. Great inventory of sports cards and Pokemon - but the thing that truly separates this place from the others is Andrew, Max, Alex and the Team. It’s just a different vibe and experience one of great energy, cooperation and enjoyment. 10 of 5 stars…keep up the great work fellas - thank you”

★★★★★

“Absolutely amazing. Was loads of fun getting to jump back into cards, 80s and 90s style 🔥🔥🔥 I just found out cards are a thing again. Donna took the time to share her wealth of knowledge about how I should go about valuing my collection. 💲🤔❓ The best part was reliving some of my sports memories from childhood. I found their prices extremely reasonable, and Donna even steered me away from pricier options and helped me get the most value for my money. I got some hobby boxes from the 90s and can't wait to open them. Even if you could find a slightly cheaper price online like some say, American Legends is by far your better option, for a few reasons. 1) You can't even put a price on their knowledge. It's invaluable, and well worth the small markup. The advice probably saved me dozens of hours sorting through what I have. 2) They have an awesome staff that's fun to talk to, about baseball cards, basketball cards or anything else sports. 3) They're right here in Westchester, NY helping to support our community. Plus, they're trustworthy. And local if you ever have a problem. Definitely worth stopping by, relive some memories about cards and then go home, and rub it in your parents face that you weren't just throwing away your money as a kid😜👌”