Best card shops in Cleveland, OH
4 shops · sorted by rating · strongest in Other TCG, Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering
CardsNearby tracks verified card shops across Cleveland — an award-winning Pokémon and Magic destination on Pearl Road, the city's oldest comic institution, and downtown's card counter — compared by specialty, services, current hours, and upcoming local shows.
Last verified Monday, September 14, 2026
Best for Pokémon
The Geek Peek (Pokemon, MTG, Gundam & OP)
★ 4.5 (213)
Best for Magic
The Geek Peek (Pokemon, MTG, Gundam & OP)
★ 4.5 (213)
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap
Which Cleveland card shop fits your need
| If you want… | Go to |
|---|---|
| Pokémon cards | The Geek Peek (Pokemon, MTG, Gundam & OP) |
| Magic & organized play | The Geek Peek (Pokemon, MTG, Gundam & OP) |
| Downtown stop | Neo Collector |
The shops, in detail
The Geek Peek — Cleveland's TCG anchor
★ 4.5 (213 Google reviews) · 4298 Pearl Rd
Voted #1 Local Game Store and #1 Collectibles Store in Best of Cleveland 2024, The Geek Peek stocks over 100,000 Pokémon singles and 20,000 Magic singles with a free 60-seat play space. Far and away the city's most complete card destination.
Carol & John's — the institution with a card aisle
★ 4.8 (702 Google reviews) · 17462 Lorain Ave
Cleveland's oldest continuously running comic shop (since 1990, founded by a mother and son) carries TCG product alongside the comics wall that earned it commendations from the city and state. Comics-first, but worth any collector's visit.
Neo Collector — the downtown counter
★ 4.8 (60 Google reviews) · 530 Euclid Ave #23
The only card stop in the downtown core, on Euclid Avenue at the 5th Street Arcades. Small but well-rated — convenient before a Guardians or Cavs game.
At a glance
| Shop | Rating | Games | Buys | Grading |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Geek Peek (Pokemon, MTG, Gundam & OP) | ★ 4.5 | Pokémon, Magic | — | — |
| Carol & John's Comic Shop | ★ 4.8 | TCG | — | — |
| North Coast Comics | ★ 4.7 | TCG | — | — |
| Neo Collector | ★ 4.8 | TCG | — | — |
More shops within 25 miles
- Superscript Comics and Games · Lakewood · 5 mi
- Doki Doki Anime & Kawaii Shop · Lakewood · 5 mi
- Absolute Legends And Collectibles · Lakewood · 6 mi
- ECH Cards and Collectibles · Parma · 6 mi
- B & L Comics Cards & Nostalgia · Parma · 7 mi
- Critical Hit Games · Cleveland Heights · 7 mi
- Gamers Haven · Parma Heights · 9 mi
- Gotz a Lot of Games · Parma · 9 mi
- B&B Sportscards · Fairview Park · 10 mi
- Dragon Door Collectibles (MTG, Pokemon) · Middleburg Heights · 10 mi
- Coach K's Sports Cards and Collectibles · Lyndhurst · 10 mi
- CLE Sports Cards & Collectibles · Broadview Heights · 10 mi
Within 50 miles
Card shows near Cleveland
J & J Sports Card Show-Mentor
Great Lakes Mall · Mentor, OH · 20 mi
TCG Concord Pokemon Show
Concord Community Center · Painesville, OH · 26 mi
Quarterly Sports and Collectibles Show
Tri-County Sports Cards · Beloit, OH · 34 mi
Vermilion Sports Card Show
Harbourtown Community Church · Vermilion, OH · 35 mi
Keep exploring
Nearby cities
Good to know
FAQ
What is the best card shop in Cleveland?
The Geek Peek on Pearl Road — Best of Cleveland 2024 winner with six figures of Pokémon singles and a free 60-seat play space. It's the anchor for both Pokémon and Magic players.
Where can I sell cards in Cleveland?
No Cleveland shop currently lists a verified buylist on CardsNearby — call ahead before bringing a collection. The Geek Peek and Marzcardz are the most established buyers to ask first.
Are there more shops in the Cleveland suburbs?
Yes — Parma and Lakewood each have their own directories with several shops, minutes from the city line.
Are there card shows near Cleveland?
Yes — recurring shows run across northeast Ohio, including monthly shows in Sandusky, Norwalk, and Hartville. See the shows section below for the next confirmed dates.