First Round Picks

★★★★★

“I went in for the first time today and mostly just planned to scope it out and maybe grab a few cheap swirl Pokemon cards as I am filling out a binder just for cards with swirls. I walked out with 3 cards with incredible swirls for less than market price since I was buying all 3 when some sellers would charge a "swirl premium." Highly recommend you check this place out. They had a good variety as well it is just on the smaller side (which inherently limits stock) but it is definitely worth checking out. It was fairly empty when I went but everyone there was nice. Especially excited about my new "third-eye and belly swirl" Mew.”

★★★★★

“Came in to sell some cards, staff and owner was very up front about what they were looking for in cards. Could see them getting excited about the ones they liked and made me fair offers on the cards. Already told some buddies to check this store out. Also it was really nice to see people playing MTG as you walk in. Thank you for a great experience, my son was overjoyed with what you offered him.”

★★★★★

“This shop is amazing!! They are so friendly and helpful and the best card shop I’ve been to. They are great with kids which is so impressive for a card shop. They have great stock, awesome prices, and are always getting new cards in and stuff to shop for. I highly recommend going here to shop because the experience is always great and meet the owners they are awesome!”

★★★★★

“I’ve recently started collecting Pokémon cards and decided to dive into completing a master set of “Journey Together.” I stopped by First Round Picks to check out their singles and was absolutely thrilled to find the top chase card! Matt was super helpful—he guided me through picking out the cards I needed and gave me fair, honest pricing on the set. The shop has such a great vibe, an awesome selection, and the team really knows their stuff. Whether you’re just starting out or a longtime collector, I highly recommend stopping in. You won’t be disappointed!”