Steve Schmitt's Sports Treasures Plus
1016 Nygaard St · Stoughton, WI 53589
Steve Schmitt's Sports Treasures Plus is a trading card shop at 1016 Nygaard St in Stoughton, Wisconsin. The shop carries Sports Cards. Store details last verified Monday, August 31, 2026.
Community rating
4.7★
Based on 27 ratings
Be the first local to vote · 4.7 on Google
Great
Rate it
Hours
- Mon
- Closed
- Tue
- 11am – 5pm
- Wed
- 11am – 5pm
- Thu
- 11am – 5pm
- Fri
- 11am – 5pm
- Sat
- 11am – 5pm
- Sun
- 11am – 5pm
Games
- Sports Cards
Services
Not verified yet — buylist, grading drop-off, and event details vary by shop.
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap
Own Steve Schmitt's Sports Treasures Plus?
Claim this listing to update hours, photos, games, and events. Free.
From Google reviews
What collectors say
★★★★★
“Checked this place out for myself today and was so pleased! It's like a little museum! Besides the tons of super interesting and historical memorabilia, there are some fun activities, like an old-school arcade game with 60 different games, a corn hole game with prizes to win, a claw machine stuffed with unique goodies and what looks like a lounge area with some antique games! Totally worth a visit! Steve is gracious and friendly and loves to swap stories. Check it out!!!”
★★★★★
“I have visited the shop multiple times with my boys and my wife. It’s absolutely fantastic.”
★★★★★
“If you are a sports fan this is a must visit place. Litterally walk in my jaw drops to the ground just priceless. Soo much sport memorabilia. The Legend Steve Schmitt done a great job with his collections here he is very passionate about sports not just pros but local High Schools too. They have every thing you look for in that store. Its defiently a Treasure hunt. From all sport cards to Bobble heads and Athelete wall decor. Highly Reccomend going. Very nice Man!”
★★★★★
“They have a great selection and the owner is a very nice person. I highly recommend checking this place out!”
Good to know
Common questions
What does Steve Schmitt's Sports Treasures Plus carry?
Steve Schmitt's Sports Treasures Plus carries Sports Cards. Call (608) 354-3389 to check current inventory.
Where is Steve Schmitt's Sports Treasures Plus located?
Steve Schmitt's Sports Treasures Plus is at 1016 Nygaard St in Stoughton, Wisconsin 53589.
Within 50 miles
Card shows nearby
Keep browsing
More shops near Stoughton
Guildpact Games★ 4.5(35)
Guildpact Games carries tabletop games and trading cards in Stoughton, WI. Open seven days a week at 1308 Hamilton St.
Gemini Games★ 4.8(183)
Gemini Games carries tabletop games and trading cards in Stoughton, WI. Open seven days a week at 193 W Main St.
Laughing Dragon Tavern Games & Collectibles★ 4.9(16)
Laughing Dragon Tavern Games & Collectibles carries tabletop games and trading cards in McFarland, WI. Open 6 days a week at 5208 Farwell St.
Misty Mountain Games★ 4.3(438)
Misty Mountain Games carries tabletop games and trading cards in Madison, WI. Open seven days a week at 4672 Cottage Grove Rd.