Paper Tiger

★★★★★

“UPDATE 4/18/26) My go to LGS in the RVA area! Have had a great time at 3 different draft events, Staff always friendly and knows everybody by name it feels like. Knowledgeable and easy going. Pack prices for MTG are always priced fairly and typically a great rotation of New sets, also anything you might need for said cards, all the way to include limited edition Playmats designed for the store! (Obviously snagged one) - Sadly didn't take photos as I was to busy taking in all the goodness!! wall to wall TCG, Comics, graded and collectors for TCG and comics. Everyone of the staff was super nice! The owner gave me a quick tour, despite a full house! tables to play, looks like a kid was having a Pokémon pizza party (kinda jealous 😅) will forsure be back.”

★★★★★

“Best card store in the entire city of Richmond. They have fair pricing on all their products, and a great selection, they do a wonderful job at helping you get what you are looking for. Julia is a great person and the backbone of this store, when I tell you, NO OTHER location comes close to the service you get here. Thank you for being AMAZING!”

★★★★★

“The best selection of sealed magic products in Richmond! They always have a steady supply of any boosters from the past few sets. Same for precon Commander decks! The real treasure in sealed products is the selection of Secret Lairs! No other shop has this many secret lairs sitting at totally reasonable prices, most are the same price u wouldve paid directly from the site. Truly the best part is the staff! They are so helpful and friendly that they feel like they are your old friends that just so happen to work at a store where they sell all your favorite stuff! My only criticism is that parking can be kind of a tetris level, with only a few spots. You may have to weirdly manuever your car into a corner and hope no one needs to leave while u run in for a pack after a bad day at work. BUT its not the store's fault and I really dont think theres anything they can do about it. SO ALL IN ALL, BEST SELECTION, AND BETTER THAN BEST STAFF!”

★★★★★

“I cannot say enough good things about our experience at Paper Tiger today! In terms of inventory, they had a ton of Pokemon cards. Their bulk cards are organized alphabetically and they have a whole wall of them. Then they have a pretty decent selection of $1 cards. Their binders are well-organized and have really great cards between $2-20. And then their superb cards in the cases are, of course, quite pricey, but the selection was good. But even more than the selection, we were impressed with the service! At first, we weren't sure if we were going to be a burden for a busy store, and we didn't know the lay of the land. But eventually, the manager Julia took us under her wing and gave us the best service I've had....maybe at any store?? She ended up giving us a few great discounts and some free swag. My son is a huge Pokemon collector, and she even went through his "good binder" and helped him understand the value of some of his cards and how to keep them in good condition. She just went so far above and beyond. We live over an hour away and we will *still* make sure to come back (often) to support this business.”