4 best MTG card shops in Appleton, WI
4 shops in and around Appleton carry Magic: The Gathering — singles walls, sealed product, and in many cases Commander nights and Friday Night Magic. Listings note league and event play where we've confirmed it.
Ranked by magic: the gathering shops-weighted CardsNearby Score · Last verified Sunday, November 8, 2026 · methodology · report a correction
| Shop | Rating | Singles | Buys | League | Distance |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Game Capital | ★ 4.3 | Yes | — | — | 2.3 mi |
| Gnome Games Appleton East | ★ 4.5 | — | — | — | 3.3 mi |
| Collecting Haven | ★ 4.5 | — | — | — | 3.4 mi |
| Slick Mimic's | ★ 4.9 | — | — | — | 1.8 mi |
The Game Capital★ 4.3(363)
TCG, Pokémon, Magic, Live breaks, Singles
Gnome Games Appleton East★ 4.5(305)
TCG, Pokémon, Magic
Collecting Haven★ 4.5(104)
TCG, Pokémon, Magic, Supplies
Slick Mimic's★ 4.9(34)
Pokémon, Magic, One Piece
Within 30 miles
Worth the drive
- Blind Tiger Games · Neenah · 7 mi
- CB Hobby · Kaukauna · 7 mi
- Windfall Games · De Pere · 21 mi
- Frost Giant Games LLC · Green Bay · 24 mi
- All Access Cardshop · Green Bay · 25 mi
- Don Father Games · Green Bay · 25 mi
Good to know
FAQ
Magic: The Gathering shops near Appleton, WI — how many options are there?
4 shops near Appleton, Wisconsin carrying Magic: The Gathering — Commander and Standard singles, sealed product, and play nights, with hours and details.
Which is the highest-rated option near Appleton?
Slick Mimic's has the highest displayed public rating at 4.9 stars across 34 reviews. Our list is ordered by a magic: the gathering shops-weighted CardsNearby Score, which also factors verified services and data completeness — see the methodology.
Browse all card shops near Appleton or the national magic: the gathering shops directory.