Sports card shops in New York
29 sports card shops across 21 municipalities in New York, ranked by CardsNearby Score.
Midtown Comics Times Square★ 4.6(9693)
Midtown Comics Times Square carries comics and trading cards in New York, NY. Open seven days a week at 200 W 40th St.
Midtown Comics Grand Central★ 4.6(2178)
Midtown Comics Grand Central carries comics and trading cards in New York, NY. Open seven days a week at 459 Lexington Ave.
Major Sports Cards★ 5.0(219)
Major Sports Cards carries sports cards and memorabilia in Mineola, NY. Open seven days a week at 466 Jericho Tpke.
Midtown Comics Astoria Outlet★ 4.6(157)
Midtown Comics Astoria Outlet carries comics and trading cards in Astoria, NY. Open 2 days a week at 32-11 41st St.
Dio’s Treasures★ 4.9(89)
Dio’s Treasures carries cards and collectibles in Le Roy, NY. Open seven days a week at 8 Lake St.
WeTheHobby★ 4.8(507)
WeTheHobby carries cards and collectibles in Rochester, NY. Open seven days a week at 23 Arlington St.
Comic Book Station★ 4.7(111)
Comic Book Station carries comics and trading cards in Brooklyn, NY. Open 5 days a week at 188 Eckford St.
CardVault by Tom Brady★ 4.6(41)
CardVault by Tom Brady carries cards and collectibles in Brooklyn, NY. Open seven days a week at 80 Flatbush Ave.
Pallet Town Poke Shop★ 4.5(182)
Pallet Town Poke Shop carries trading card games and singles in Depew, NY. Open seven days a week at 6055 Transit Rd.
Montasy Comics NYC★ 4.1(1106)
Montasy Comics NYC carries comics and trading cards in New York, NY. Open seven days a week at 431 5th Ave 2nd floor.
GG Cards & Breaks★ 4.6(84)
GG Cards & Breaks carries sports cards and memorabilia in Syracuse, NY. Open 6 days a week at 639 Delmar Pl.
Great Lakes Sports Cards★ 5.0(38)
Great Lakes Sports Cards carries sports cards and memorabilia in Buffalo, NY. Open seven days a week at 4161 Transit Rd.
Astro Game★ 4.1(226)
Astro Game carries tabletop games and trading cards in New York, NY. Open seven days a week at 1461 St. Nicholas Ave.
Diamond Club Cards & Collectibles★ 4.6(36)
Diamond Club Cards & Collectibles carries cards and collectibles in Phelps, NY. Open 6 days a week at 256 Main St.
Breakcity Cards & Memorabilia★ 4.8(143)
Breakcity Cards & Memorabilia carries sports cards and memorabilia in Buffalo, NY. Open seven days a week at 4408 Milestrip Rd.
Big Slab Daddy Sport Cards★ 4.9(100)
Big Slab Daddy Sport Cards carries sports cards and memorabilia in Brooklyn, NY. Open seven days a week at 8115 3rd Ave.
Bogarts Sports Cards★ 5.0(58)
Bogarts Sports Cards carries sports cards and memorabilia in Averill Park, NY. Open 2 days a week at 10 Sheer Rd.
E and J Boutique Sports Cards★ 4.7(308)
E and J Boutique Sports Cards carries sports cards and memorabilia in Brooklyn, NY. Open seven days a week at 6906 Fort Hamilton Pkwy.
Leone’s Collectibles★ 4.2(43)
Leone’s Collectibles carries cards and collectibles in Rochester, NY. Open 6 days a week at 612 Stone Rd.
Salt City Sports Cards★ 5.0(25)
Salt City Sports Cards carries sports cards and memorabilia in Manlius, NY. Open 6 days a week at 123 E Seneca St.
Everything else
All matching shops
- 510 Toy Shop and Sports Cards · Orchard Park
- Bases Loaded Sports Collectibles · East Aurora
- Finnigan's Sportscards · Albany
- 716 Sports Cards & Collectibles · West Seneca
- The Family Hobby Sports Cards & TCG · Canastota
- JC'S Cards and Collectibles · Spencerport
- Al's House of Sportscards · Schenectady
- Game On Sports Memorabilia Southtowns · Hamburg
- Southpaw Sports Cards · Cicero
Good to know
FAQ
How many sports card shops are in New York?
CardsNearby lists 29 sports card shops across 21 New York municipalities, ranked by CardsNearby Score.
Which New York city is strongest for this?
Brooklyn, New York lead with the most matching shops — each has a dedicated local page below.