The best card shops in Wisconsin, ranked
The top 15 of Wisconsin's card shops by CardsNearby Score — a 0–100 ranking built from rating strength, review depth, specialization, and verified services (no paid placement, ever). This year's list is strongest in Pokémon, Other TCG, Magic: The Gathering. See how we rank.
- 1Noble Knight GamesScore 87
Fitchburg, WI · ★ 4.7 (1536) · TCG, Pokémon, Magic
Noble Knight Games carries tabletop games and trading cards in Fitchburg, WI. Open seven days a week at 2835 Commerce Park Dr.
Buys collections · All Fitchburg shops →
- 2Case Hit MKEScore 84
Franklin, WI · ★ 4.9 (41) · Sports, Pokémon, Lorcana
Case Hit MKE carries cards and collectibles in Franklin, WI. Open 6 days a week at 7009 S 27th St.
Buys collections · Grading drop-off · All Franklin shops →
- 3Imperial GamesScore 83
West Allis, WI · ★ 4.9 (207) · TCG, Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh!
Imperial Games carries tabletop games and trading cards in West Allis, WI. Open 6 days a week at 8633 W Greenfield Ave.
- 4
Madison, WI · ★ 4.9 (295) · Sports, Pokémon, Magic
Slab Factory - Sports & Trading Cards carries sports cards and memorabilia in Madison, WI. Open seven days a week at 739 N High Point Rd.
- 5HoneyBee GamesScore 79
Glendale, WI · ★ 4.8 (98) · TCG, Pokémon, Magic
HoneyBee Games carries tabletop games and trading cards in Glendale, WI. Open 5 days a week at 6805 N Green Bay Ave.
- 6Cosmic Destroyer’s CollectiblesScore 78
Shorewood, WI · ★ 4.7 (134) · TCG, Pokémon, Magic
Cosmic Destroyer’s Collectibles carries cards and collectibles in Shorewood, WI. Open 5 days a week at 1920 E Capitol Dr.
- 7Start Over GamesScore 77
Oshkosh, WI · ★ 4.8 (222) · TCG, Pokémon, Sports
Start Over Games carries tabletop games and trading cards in Oshkosh, WI. Open 6 days a week at 2285 Westowne Ave.
- 8Pink Bunny GamesScore 75
South Milwaukee, WI · ★ 4.1 (426) · TCG, Pokémon, Magic
Pink Bunny Games carries tabletop games and trading cards in South Milwaukee, WI. Open seven days a week at 1204 Minnesota Ave.
Buys collections · All South Milwaukee shops →
- 9Game HavenScore 75
Waunakee, WI · ★ 4.8 (94) · TCG, Magic, Pokémon
Game Haven carries tabletop games and trading cards in Waunakee, WI. Open seven days a week at 229 S Century Ave.
- 10AB Sports Cards & CollectiblesScore 75
Brown Deer, WI · ★ 4.8 (36) · Sports, Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh!
AB Sports Cards & Collectibles carries sports cards and memorabilia in Brown Deer, WI. Open 6 days a week at 4324 W Bradley Rd.
Grading drop-off · All Brown Deer shops →
- 11Misty Mountain GamesScore 74
Madison, WI · ★ 4.3 (438) · TCG, Pokémon, Magic
Misty Mountain Games carries tabletop games and trading cards in Madison, WI. Open seven days a week at 4672 Cottage Grove Rd.
Buys collections · All Madison shops →
- 12Warpstorm Games & LoungeScore 74
Greenfield, WI · ★ 4.7 (181) · TCG, Pokémon, Magic
Warpstorm Games & Lounge carries tabletop games and trading cards in Greenfield, WI. Open seven days a week at 6120 W Layton Ave.
- 13CB HobbyScore 74
Kaukauna, WI · ★ 4.4 (83) · TCG, Pokémon, Magic
CB Hobby carries cards and collectibles in Kaukauna, WI. Open 5 days a week at 200 E 2nd St Ste C.
Grading drop-off · All Kaukauna shops →
- 14Valhalla HobbyScore 74
Verona, WI · ★ 4.7 (46) · TCG, Magic, One Piece
Valhalla Hobby carries cards and collectibles in Verona, WI. Open 5 days a week at 535 Half Mile Rd Suite 5B.
- 15Board Game BarristerScore 73
Glendale, WI · ★ 4.6 (256) · TCG, Lorcana, Pokémon
Board Game Barrister carries tabletop games and trading cards in Glendale, WI. Open seven days a week at 5754 N Bayshore Dr.
Good to know
FAQ
What is the best card shop in Wisconsin?
Noble Knight Games in Fitchburg holds the top CardsNearby Score in Wisconsin, with Case Hit MKE (Franklin) close behind. Rankings weigh rating strength, review depth, specialization, and verified services.
Which of Wisconsin's best shops buy collections?
4 of the top 15 run verified buylists, including Noble Knight Games, Case Hit MKE, Pink Bunny Games. Call ahead for large collections.
Which top Wisconsin shops take grading drop-offs?
Case Hit MKE, AB Sports Cards & Collectibles, CB Hobby accept grading submissions or drop-offs — confirm current turnaround tiers with the shop.
How are these rankings decided?
The CardsNearby Score (0–100) combines public rating signal, review volume, verified specialization, and confirmed services — no shop can pay for placement. See our methodology page for details.
Browse the full directory: 90 card shops in Wisconsin →