Best card shops in Madison, WI

13 shops · sorted by rating · strongest in Other TCG, Sports Cards, Pokémon

There are 13 card shops in and around Madison, WI, led by Slab Factory - Sports & Trading Cards (★ 4.9). 1 buy collections and 1 accept grading drop-offs. Strongest in Other TCG, Sports Cards, Pokémon.

Best for Pokémon

Slab Factory - Sports & Trading Cards

★ 4.9 (295)

Best for Sports cards

Slab Factory - Sports & Trading Cards

★ 4.9 (295)

Best for Magic

Slab Factory - Sports & Trading Cards

★ 4.9 (295)

Best for Selling a collection

Misty Mountain Games

★ 4.3 (438)

Pokémon shops →Sports card shops →

4 Pokémon card vending machines in Madison →

13 shops

Sorted by CardsNearby Score

Slab Factory - Sports & Trading Cards★ 4.9(295)

Sports, Pokémon, Magic, Singles, Supplies

Slab Factory - Sports & Trading Cards carries sports cards and memorabilia in Madison, WI. Open seven days a week at 739 N High Point Rd.

SportsPokémonMagicSinglesSupplies

5.9 mi

Misty Mountain Games★ 4.3(438)

TCG, Pokémon, Magic, Buylist, League play

Misty Mountain Games carries tabletop games and trading cards in Madison, WI. Open seven days a week at 4672 Cottage Grove Rd.

TCGPokémonMagicBuylistLeague play

5.1 mi

Pegasus Games★ 4.4(380)

TCG, Pokémon, Lorcana, League play, Singles

Pegasus Games carries tabletop games and trading cards in Madison, WI. Open seven days a week at 6640 Odana Rd.

TCGPokémonLorcanaLeague playSingles

4.8 mi

Graham Crackers Comics of Wisconsin★ 4.7(334)

TCG, Grading drop-off, Supplies

Graham Crackers Comics of Wisconsin carries comics and trading cards in Madison, WI. Open seven days a week at 2831 E Washington Ave.

TCGGrading drop-offSupplies

3.5 mi

Gamer's Library★ 4.8(397)

TCG

Gamer's Library carries tabletop games and trading cards in Madison, WI. Open seven days a week at 449 State St Units C/D.

TCG

0.4 mi

Geeks Mania Arcade★ 4.7(1766)

TCG

Geeks Mania Arcade carries cards and collectibles in Madison, WI. Open seven days a week at 6502 Odana Rd.

TCG

4.7 mi

Westfield Comics - West★ 4.7(293)

TCG

Westfield Comics - West carries comics and trading cards in Madison, WI. Open seven days a week at 7475 Mineral Point Rd #22.

TCG

5.7 mi

Sigs Treasure Chest★ 4.9(69)

TCG

Sigs Treasure Chest carries cards and collectibles in Madison, WI. Open 5 days a week at 222 North St.

TCG

3.3 mi

Name of the Game★ 4.1(30)

TCG, Sports, League play, Live breaks

Name of the Game carries tabletop games and trading cards in Madison, WI. Open seven days a week at 22 W Towne Mall.

TCGSportsLeague playLive breaks

5.4 mi

VIDEO GAME X-CHANGE★ 4.6(441)

TCG

VIDEO GAME X-CHANGE carries tabletop games and trading cards in Madison, WI. Open seven days a week at 3002 Atwood Ave.

TCG

3.4 mi

Rabbit Hole Sports Cards★ 4.7(43)

Sports

Rabbit Hole Sports Cards carries sports cards and memorabilia in Madison, WI. Open 6 days a week at 150 E Towne Way.

Sports

6.2 mi

Capital City Comics★ 4.2(129)

TCG

Capital City Comics carries comics and trading cards in Madison, WI. Open 6 days a week at 1910 Monroe St.

TCG

1.0 mi

Jim's Card Korner LLC★ 4.0(85)

Jim's Card Korner LLC carries cards and collectibles in Madison, WI. Open seven days a week at 2865 University Ave.

1.9 mi

At a glance

Shop	Rating	Games	Buys	Grading
Slab Factory - Sports & Trading Cards	★ 4.9	Sports, Pokémon, Magic	—	—
Misty Mountain Games	★ 4.3	TCG, Pokémon, Magic	Yes	—
Pegasus Games	★ 4.4	TCG, Pokémon, Lorcana	—	—
Graham Crackers Comics of Wisconsin	★ 4.7	TCG	—	Drop-off
Gamer's Library	★ 4.8	TCG	—	—
Geeks Mania Arcade	★ 4.7	TCG	—	—
Westfield Comics - West	★ 4.7	TCG	—	—
Sigs Treasure Chest	★ 4.9	TCG	—	—
Name of the Game	★ 4.1	TCG, Sports	—	—
VIDEO GAME X-CHANGE	★ 4.6	TCG	—	—

More shops within 25 miles

I'm Board! Games & Family Fun - Middleton · Middleton · 5 mi
Noble Knight Games · Fitchburg · 6 mi
Quicksave Games · Fitchburg · 6 mi
Laughing Dragon Tavern Games & Collectibles · McFarland · 7 mi
Game Haven · Waunakee · 9 mi
I'm Board! Games & Family Fun - Sun Prairie · Sun Prairie · 9 mi
Valhalla Hobby · Verona · 9 mi
Bonsai Cards & Collectibles · DeForest · 12 mi
Steve Schmitt's Sports Treasures Plus · Stoughton · 13 mi
Guildpact Games · Stoughton · 14 mi
Gemini Games · Stoughton · 14 mi

13 shops in view

Within 50 miles

Card shows near Madison

All shows near here →

Madison Card Show

Alliant Energy Center Exhibition Hall · Madison, WI · 2 mi

SportsPokémon

Several times a year

Collector's Vault

Middleton Conference Center · Middleton, WI · 6 mi

Sports

occasional touring stops

Keep exploring

Nearby cities

Middleton

1 shop · 5 mi

Fitchburg

2 shops · 6 mi

McFarland

1 shop · 7 mi

Waunakee

1 shop · 9 mi

Good to know

FAQ

How many card shops are near Madison, WI?

There are 13 card shops in and around Madison, Wisconsin listed on CardsNearby, carrying Other TCG, Sports Cards, Pokémon and more.

Where can I sell cards in Madison?

1 of the 13 card shops in Madison run an active buylist and buy collections, including Misty Mountain Games. Call ahead for large collections.

Are there card shows near Madison?

Yes — 2 card shows run within 50 miles of Madison, including Madison Card Show. See each show page for upcoming dates.

Which Madison stores sell trading card games (TCG)?

11 of the 13 card shops in and around Madison are TCG stores carrying Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh!, or other trading card games — including Slab Factory - Sports & Trading Cards and Misty Mountain Games.