Card shops in Indiana
71 qualifying card shops across 22 Indiana municipalities, organized into 22 metro-area directories — strongest in Other TCG, Magic: The Gathering, Pokémon. Each listing has hours, games carried, and services like buylists and grading drop-off.
Data last refreshed Thursday, October 15, 2026. CardsNearby includes physical card and hobby stores with posted hours and an established review history; store hours, ratings and services are refreshed approximately every 30 days. See our methodology or report a correction.
Indianapolis
24 shops
Fort Wayne
12 shops
Evansville
11 shops
South Bend
2 shops
Greenwood
2 shops
Elkhart
2 shops
Mishawaka
2 shops
Granger
2 shops
Fishers
1 shop
Carmel
1 shop
Greenfield
1 shop
Plainfield
1 shop
Brownsburg
1 shop
Osceola
1 shop
Columbia City
1 shop
Danville
1 shop
New Buffalo
1 shop
Huntington
1 shop
Milford
1 shop
Henderson
1 shop
Avon
1 shop
Speedway
1 shop
Highest rated
Top card shops in Indiana
| Shop | City | Google rating | Games | Buys |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Upscale Trading Cards | Evansville | ★ 4.8 (156) | Pokémon, Magic, Sports | Yes |
| The Hobby Den | Evansville | ★ 4.9 (854) | TCG, Pokémon, Sports | Yes |
| CLEVER BAY SPORTS & GAMING | Evansville | ★ 4.7 (137) | Sports, Pokémon, Magic | Yes |
| Paradigm Games | Indianapolis | ★ 4.7 (130) | TCG, Pokémon, Magic | Yes |
| Game World | Indianapolis | ★ 4.8 (303) | TCG, Pokémon, Magic | Yes |
| Gray Gauntlet Games | Indianapolis | ★ 4.7 (91) | TCG, Pokémon, Magic | Yes |
| Mage's Comics and Games | Indianapolis | ★ 4.8 (200) | TCG, Pokémon, Magic | — |
| Family Time Games | Indianapolis | ★ 4.8 (820) | TCG, Pokémon, Magic | — |
| Atomic Planet Comics | Fishers | ★ 4.8 (88) | TCG, Pokémon, Magic | — |
| Best Card Shop | Plainfield | ★ 4.7 (183) | Pokémon, Magic, Yu-Gi-Oh! | — |
| Books Comics & Things | Fort Wayne | ★ 4.6 (348) | TCG, Pokémon, Magic | — |
| Saltire Toys & Games | Indianapolis | ★ 4.7 (329) | TCG, Pokémon, Magic | — |
| Hot Spot Collectibles and Toys LLC | Brownsburg | ★ 4.7 (262) | TCG, Sports | Yes |
| k0s Card Shop | Avon | ★ 4.2 (88) | Pokémon, Magic, Lorcana | Yes |
| Comic Quest | Evansville | ★ 4.5 (629) | TCG, Pokémon, Magic | — |
Complete directory
Every listed shop, by city
Indianapolis area
- Paradigm Games
- Game World
- Gray Gauntlet Games
- Mage's Comics and Games
- Family Time Games
- Saltire Toys & Games
- Elf 'N Moon Gaming & Hobby
- Game Preserve
- Indy Card Exchange
- The Toy Pit
- Indy Card Shop
- Game Time
- The Game Preserve
- Comic Carnival
- Good Games Indianapolis
- Downtown Comics
- Downtown Comics In Castleton
- Collectors Emporium
- Vintage Indy Sports
- Grandmaster Games
- ComicsPriceGuide
- Raven's Comics, Collectibles & Books
- Collectors Paradise
- The Card Depot
By specialty
Specialty guides
The best card shops in Indiana, ranked →
Events
Card shows in Indiana
Card Show at The Eyrie
Eyrie Event Space/Roots Market · Plainfield, IN
JJ All Star Sportscards Show
Fishers American Legion Post 470 · Fishers, IN
Collectors Palooza
Indiana State Fairgrounds & Event Center · Indianapolis, IN
Seymour Card Show
Buckets Basketball Training · Seymour, IN
Good to know
FAQ
How many card shops are in Indiana?
CardsNearby lists 71 qualifying card shops across 22 Indiana municipalities, organized into 22 metro-area directories. Listings are physical sports card shops and trading card game (TCG) stores with posted hours and an established review history.
Which Indiana stores sell trading card games (TCG)?
55 of the 71 listed Indiana shops are TCG stores carrying Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh!, or other trading card games — including Upscale Trading Cards and The Hobby Den. Filter any city page by game to find TCG stores near you.
Which Indiana city has the most card shops?
Indianapolis has the most listings, with 24 shops in and around the city.
Where can I sell cards in Indiana?
16 of the 71 Indiana shops listed run an active buylist or buy collections, including Game World and The Hobby Den. Check each listing's services and call ahead for large collections.
Are there card shows in Indiana?
Yes — 27 recurring card shows are listed in Indiana. See the Indiana show calendar for upcoming dates, venues and admission.